And sometimes there’s not an easy answer.
What is justice?
What is redemption? How do we decide when a person is redeemed? Are there crimes that are beyond redemption?
What is the purpose of prison? What should our goals be when we lock people up? Protection of society? Punishment? Reform?
How should we treat young people who commit horrible crimes? Do we lock them away for life? Do we give them a chance to reform? What if we’re wrong, and reform doesn’t take?
Greg Ousley is serving a 60 year sentence in the Indiana prison system. He’s been there since 1994. In that time, he’s earned a degree in liberal arts from Indiana State (summa cum laude, no less). The corrections staff at his prison apparently thinks the world of Mr. Ousley.
His former work supervisor, Cindy Estes, was more explicit. “This kid has jumped through every hoop the state has put in front of him,” she told me. “He deserves to come out. There’s absolutely nothing to be gained by keeping him in there for another 10 years.”
He’ll be eligible for parole in March of 2019, unless a judge agrees to modify his sentence.
What did Mr. Ousley do? At the age of 14, he shotgunned his parents to death.
I don’t know what to do with Mr. Ousley. I don’t claim to know whether he’s reformed enough that he deserves to be let out. I don’t have answers to those questions. The only thing I have is the knowledge that I’m glad I don’t work in the justice system, because I don’t have those answers.